New Unit Development with AI

Claude and Gemini sit in as thinking partners — never as the author.

September 25 PD Day · Breakout led by Greg

A Coaching Stance, Not a Tech Tutorial

This session is

  • A mediated conversation — you ask, the AI answers
  • Nonjudgmental of yourself, just ask and see what happens.
  • AI treated as one more voice in the room, not the decision maker

This session is not

  • An evaluation of you or your abilities
  • A demo where the AI writes the unit and you just approve it
  • A replacement for the teacher’s own judgment about students

Guardrails Before We Open a Chat Window

No student data goes in

Names, grades, IEP details, and identifiable work stay out of any AI tool. Talk in generalities: “a student who struggles with sequencing,” not a name.

Drafts, not directives

Everything the AI produces is a starting point to react to, revise, or discard — never a final answer to accept as-is.

The teacher stays the author

Whatever the tool suggests, the unit still needs to sound and think like YOU.

Step 1

Clarify Goals

Ask yourself

  • “What do you want students to walk away understanding by the end of this unit?” Consider designing or using a learning objective.
  • “Why does this matter for these students, right now?” Consider how this unit might impact their learning.

Try in Claude or Gemini

I’m designing a unit on [topic] for [grade/level]. Suggest 3–4 possible big-picture learning objective/outcomes, phrased as things students will understand or be able to do.

Step 2

Specify Success Indicators

Determine what counts as acceptable evidence of mastery (both formative and summative) before planning lessons.

Ask yourself

“What would you see or hear students doing that tells you that students have achieved mastery of the learning objectives or outcomes?”

Try in Claude or Gemini

Given these outcomes, suggest observable indicators of student understanding, and two or three low-lift ways to collect evidence during the unit.

Possible final products

Individual activitiesGroup workStudents make presentationsStudents write a final productQuiz or testFormative assessments along the way

Step 3

Anticipate Approaches

Ask

“What strategies or activities might get students there?”
  • I would like to design a problem based learning unit, what are current teaching methods that support this type of learning?
  • I would like to create lessons that are adaptive to different types of learning styles, what are current teaching methods that support many learning styles?
  • When researching, use these kinds of sources: ______.
  • When designing the activity, keep in mind my students are ______.

Try in Claude or Gemini

Generate a range of instructional strategies and a possible activity sequence for this unit.

Add to it:

  • I want this unit to be inquiry-based and solve real-life problems.
  • I want students to collaborate with specified roles.
  • I want students to explain their process to another student.


Or: I am unsure about how to support student learning within this unit, what are ways to help students with ______.

Sentence & Question Starters

Learning objectives

  • By the end of this unit, students will be able to ______.
  • The big idea I want them to walk away with is ______.
  • This matters to these students right now because ______.

“What do I want students to understand, not just complete?”

Strategies and methods

  • I want this unit to be ______ (inquiry-based, hands-on, collaborative).
  • When students work in groups, I want them to ______.
  • The sequence I’m imagining starts with ______ and builds to ______.
  • Or: I am unsure what is best and need help researching current methods. What are…

“What strategy fits how these students learn best?”

Final products

  • Students will show their learning by ______.
  • I’ll know students are meeting expectations if I see or hear ______.
  • The evidence I’ll collect along the way includes ______.

“What would make this final product worth the time it takes?”

Claude and Gemini, Side by Side

ClaudeGemini
Where it shinesLong, multi-turn drafting — shaping goals and rubrics over several exchanges. Project organization is cleaner.Working right inside Docs, Slides, and other Workspace files; strong at generating images.
Use it here forBrainstorming outcomes, strategies, and research.Google-aligned tools with easy, free access through our teacher accounts.
Keep in mindOne focused thread per unit; export or copy out the final plan. Do not use student personal information.Check anything it pulls from a linked file before trusting it. Do not use student personal information.

Either works. Pick the one you already reach for.

A Language Toolkit

Pause

Let three to five seconds sit after a question — before and after you get a response. If you’re uncertain what the answer is, ask the AI. No judgment, no fear, no consequences to you as a person.

Paraphrase

Reflect back what you heard: “So the heart of it is students seeing themselves as scientists.” Or: “The direction this unit is going isn’t quite what I’m looking for — I’d rather it go ______.”

Probe

Open, non-judgmental follow-ups: “Would it be possible to do this in 3 days?” or “How could I ensure authenticity of student work?”

Steps 1–3, at a Glance

1

Clarify Goals

“What do I want students to walk away understanding?”
Output: a big-picture learning objective.
2

Specify Success Indicators

“What would tell me students are meeting expectations?”
Output: evidence to collect and a final product.
3

Anticipate Approaches

“What strategies get students there?”
Output: an activity sequence that fits these students.

Where we go from here: plan one unit together, then teach it and meet again to reflect.